Medical arguments provide a strong case against abortion and for life. The best legal argument against abortion can be seen in the case of Roe v. It violated standard legal reasoning. The Supreme Court decided not to decide when life begins and then turned around and overturned the laws of 50 different states. Although the sentences sounded both innocuous and unpretentious, they were neither.
It overturned state laws that protected the unborn and has resulted in over 30 million abortions roughly the population of Canada in the United States. The decision also seems unpretentious by acknowledging that it did not know when life begins. A crucial role of government is to protect life.
Government cannot remove a segment of the human population from its protection without adequate justification. The burden of proof should lie with the life-taker, and the benefit of the doubt should be with the life-saver. The burden of proof in law is on the prosecution. The benefit of doubt is with the defense.
This is also known as a presumption of innocence. The defendant is assumed to be innocent unless proven guilty. Again the burden of proof is on the entity that would take away life or liberty. The benefit of the doubt lies with the defense. The Supreme Court clearly stated that it does not know when life begins and then violated the very spirit of this legal principle by acting as if it just proved that no life existed in the womb.
Even more curious was the fact that to do so, it had to ignore the religious community and international community on the subject of the unborn. Had the religious community really failed to reach a consensus? Although there were some intramural disagreements, certainly the weight of evidence indicated that a Western culture founded on Judeo-Christian values held abortion to be morally wrong.
People with widely divergent theological perspectives Jewish, Catholic, evangelical and fundamental Protestants shared a common agreement about the humanity of the unborn. The same could be said about the international legal community. The unborn were protected by various international documents like the Declaration of Geneva and the U. Declaration of the Rights of the Child.
Just as there are solid medical arguments against abortion, so also there are legal arguments against abortion. Wade was a bad decision that needs to be overturned. A third set of arguments against abortion would be philosophical arguments. A key philosophical question is where do you draw the line? Put another way, when does a human being become a person? Wade separated personhood from humanity.
In other words, the judges argued that a developing fetus was a human i. Since only persons are given 14th Amendment protection under the Constitution, the Court argued that abortion could be legal at certain times.
This left to doctors, parents, or even other judges the responsibility of arbitrarily deciding when personhood should be awarded to human beings. Once the Court allowed people to start drawing lines, some drew them in unexpected ways and effectively opened the door for infanticide and euthanasia. In the past, such criteria as implantation or quickening had been suggested.
The Court chose the idea of viability and allowed for the possibility that states could outlaw abortions performed after a child was viable. But viability was an arbitrary criterion, and there was no biological reason why the line had to be drawn near the early stages of development. The line, for example, could be drawn much later. Ethicist Paul Ramsey frequently warned that any argument for abortion could logically be also used as an argument for infanticide. As if to illustrate this, Dr.
Francis Crick, of DNA fame, demonstrated that he was less concerned about the ethics of such logical extensions and proposed a more radical definition of personhood. Other line-drawers have suggested a cultural criterion for personhood. It is also an argument for infanticide. More recently some line-drawers have focused on a mental criterion for personhood. In conclusion, we can see that there are many good arguments against abortion.
Obviously there are a number of biblical arguments against abortion. But there are also medical, legal, and philosophical arguments against abortion. The Bible and logic are on the side of the Christian who wants to stand for the sanctity of human life. Note from Kerby Anderson: So many people ask for more information on abortion; I suggest you check out the Abortion Facts Web site at www. In my "Introduction to Ethics" class, the topic for the night was abortion. As the discussion progressed, people all around me were saying that an abortion is good to do….
A Commitment to Gruesomeness This year is the twenty-seventh year of legal abortion, and the only thing that appears to have changed in the debate is the addition of newer….
Sue Bohlin takes a hard look at abortion from a biblical perspective. Dear Sue, I just read your article on abortion as a source to prepare a message on abortion. Thank you for a well written, well documented work. Sue Bohlin looks at the common effects of an abortion on the women who choose it. From a biblical worldview perspective, it is not surprising that many women experience guilt,….
The grisly effects of over twenty years of an abortion industry in this country are becoming easier to document all the time. There can also be other instances where abortion is preferable. But situations where mothers do it for no good reasons have to be strongly condemned. And at the end, you must conclude all the reasons and restate your statement about abortion differently because repeating it in the same words will destroy your impression.
At the very end should lay the concluding statement. Writing a persuasive essay against abortion Abortion has become a conflicting issue during past several years due to its tremendous rate of increase. Fetus is a whole living being. You cannot choose to abort him just because it cannot speak for its right or it is not able to choose. Abortion is simply a murder because you are killing a living being for your own interests or reasons.
You never know that what a big personality that baby can be. Considering the suffering that unwanted birth causes, it is better to allow abortion so that termination happens before life takes hold outside the womb.
Unwanted children are often neglected, put up for adoption, or are pushed into prostitution and crime by parents that do not have their best interests at heart. It results in a life of misery and heartache for the child. People that do not support abortion do not have adopted children. It would be far easier to digest a no-abortion stance from a person that has adopted children, and yet most if not all do not have adopted children.
They are basically sending the message that all pregnancies should be taken to term but once the child is out of the womb then they are on their own. The lack of support for neglected and orphan children is already at a level that is going to make people in the future look back and frown in the same way we frown at our ancestors for their treatment of other races.
Unwanted pregnancy ruins the lives of good people.
Abortion Essay “It is a mistake to reject religious principles in favour of secular/ethical principles for guidance in medical ethics” Examine and comment on this claim with reference to the topic you have investigated (50 marks) Abortion is the deliberate termination of a pregnancy after the fertilisation of the human ovum and before birth.
Buy an "Arguments For or Against Abortion" Essay - We Offer Only Original Papers As already said before, there are many issues to discuss when it comes to the abortion question. There are a few directions you could choose.
The word abortion by definition means the induced expulsion of a fetus from the womb before it is able to survive independently. Abortion is an extremely controversial issue because while some people are completely against it, others believe that a woman should have the right to choose. I believe /5(9). Free Essays from Bartleby | Argument against HRSDC Arguments against HRSDC In the year , the government of Canada announced the creation of two new.
- Abortion is a controversial subject for those who feel strongly against abortion will try to convince women to change her mind. In the article, “My Abortion “, by Meaghan Winter explains that some clinics been shut down to end the process of abortion. Abortion is an extremely controversial issue because while some people are completely against it, others believe that a woman should have the right to choose. I believe that abortion .